Opaque - People Don’t Fail, Leaders Do, Part II


Opaque

People Don’t Fail, Leaders Do, Part II, by Jimmie Santee



Originally published Sep/Oct 2014 PS Magazine



As reported in the USA Today last February 21, Ashley Wagner called the ISU judging rules, “too opaque.” “It’s not clear enough to the audience and it needs to be more fan friendly so that we can get a wider fan base,” she said, “I think we need to get rid of the anonymous judging.” Millions of fans reportedly signed a petition demanding a full investigation, and eventually, both the Korean Skating Union and Korean Olympic Committee filed a complaint with the ISU against Ms. Alla Shekhovtseva, the Russian judge and wife of Valentin Piseev, the General Director of the Russian Figure Skating Federation. Shekhovtseva was seen hugging Adelina Sotnikova, the newly crowned Olympic gold medalist in the media mix zone.



Many who watched the Ladies event thought that Yuna would win her second Olympic gold. I was in that group, and in my opinion, the gold medal race was closer between Yuna and Carolina Kostner.



But…I’m not going to discuss the results any further because of anonymous judging. While everyone could see the protocols, there was no direct proof that the judging was biased. I mean we could see it and smell it… but there was no smoking gun regarding the marks. No Assessments (the term used by the ISU to discipline judges for judging errors) were given.

Point in case – while the Korean Skating Union and Korean Olympic Committee filed a complaint with the ISU, it was for an alleged conflict of interest. Their Complaint led off with this paragraph:



We respectfully submit this formal complaint (this “Complaint”) to the Disciplinary Commission of the International Skating Union (the “DC”) and request for action to be carried out in connection with the wrongful constitution of the panel of judges and the unjust outcome of the competition caused thereby in the ladies’ single figure skating competition (the “Competition”) at the 2014 Sochi Winter Olympic Games which were held from 19th to 20th February 2014 at the Iceberg Skating Palace in Sochi, Russia.


A second complaint by the Koreans objected to Shekhovtseva hugging Sotnikova in the mixed zone. With her marriage to Piseev, the Koreans viewed her inclusion in the judging pool as a conflict of interest and suggested her allegiance to her husband, the Russian Federation, and the Russian skaters impacted her independence. The Russians reply, “Congratulating a champion and winner of the gold medal in the opinion of the Alleged Offender is not a violation of rules but a normal gesture and an appreciation of the skater’s hard work.”


A Readers Digest version of the ISU’s answer to the complaint:



Statement from the ISU, “Article 24 Paragraph 1 of the ISU Constitution 2012 provides, in part, as follows: The DC serves as a first instance authority to hear and decide all charges referred to it by any ISU authority or party against any Skater, Official, Office Holder or other participant in ISU activities (Alleged Offender) accused of a disciplinary or ethical offence (Offence).”

The result:



Complaint #1 is inadmissible and must be dismissed.

Complaint #2 is dismissed. “… It gives the impression to the Panel, that the skater instigated the embrace and the Alleged Offender did not refuse but returned the hug and kissed the skater.


The upsetting part of this whole debacle is that the core issue of anonymous judging was never addressed; basically because the ISU rules don’t allow for transparency or the right to challenge it.



In my last editorial, which was written prior to the ISU Congress in Dublin, Ireland, I was highly critical of Cinquanta’s ISU presidency and listed his many faults and failures as a leader. The list continues to grow. At this recent congress, there was a proposal to eliminate anonymous judging. As a rule, the ISU Congress needs a two thirds vote for the proposal to pass. Beverly Smith, a long time reporter for Toronto’s Globe and Mail, reported that a source told her the vote was close; 30 voted yes, 24 no, and two abstained. Abstained? More surprisingly, Russia voted to change the rule and South Korea did not.



I love a good Machiavellian plot… South Korea hosts the next Olympics and votes to keep judging anonymous…to their advantage?…revenge? The Russians got what they wanted; total domination (almost) of the Olympic Figure Skating event on home soil. Why change the rule? The list of who voted down the proposal included former Soviet bloc countries: Latvia, Estonia, Lithuania, Belarus, Georgia, Poland, and Slovakia. If Russia was able to do the math, they could vote for the proposal and come out looking like the good guy… to be continued!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Forgotten Art of Skating Etiquette

Image
PS Magazine, OCT/NOV 2010 This past September, I was in San Francisco for both the PSA Nationwide and ISI seminars. I was excited to be there as I was unveiling a new presentation/soapbox, "The Forgotten Art of Skating Etiquette." But before I was scheduled to deliver my new PowerPoint, I had an on-ice presentation to do. Standing in the middle of the rink finishing up my session, you can imagine my surprise as I was interrupted by this gentle voice from behind. "Excuse me Mr. Santee, I am sorry to interrupt…I’m warming up for my test and I need to use the middle of the ice…Is that OK?" I turned and just stared at him in stunned silence…Did he just call me Mr. Santee? Is he asking my permission to use ice he already had a right too? WOW was all I could think, and "Sure" was all I managed to say. Turning toward the coaches standing there, I said, "I’ll even get out of his way." I was so impressed with his demeanor that I thought to myself that if ...
Read more

Under Siege – Our Youth

It’s not figure skating. It’s not hockey. It’s not gymnastics or swimming, nor football or basketball…it is our children who are under siege. In 2010, a jury awarded a former scout $18.5 million dollars after the Boy Scouts of America was accused of covering up decades of child abuse. The Catholic Church has had to defend accusations from Canada, Ireland, United States, Britain, Mexico, Belgium, France, and Germany. Every year there is a plethora of accusations against school teachers….as recently as yesterday, a university professor was accused of watching child pornography on an airplane! As a father I used to worry about the influence of drinking and drugs to my children…as a culture, we turn to the church, the scouts, school activities, or sports to help keep our children off the streets and away from harm. But that seems not to be the case… and quite honestly, it is very difficult if not impossible to protect our children from the “landmines” that surround them. It’s not these act...
Read more

Girls - Hockey vs. Figure Skating

Jan/Feb 2013 PS Magazine In the November issue of USA Hockey magazine it was reported that in the past 10 years, participation in girl’s hockey has increased close to 40%; for the 2011-2012 season, 67,000 girls and women were playing hockey. If USA Hockey can maintain that pace, the number of girls playing hockey could exceed those who are figure skating within another 20 years. While rink owners and operators would love that, it should concern those who earn their livelihood in the figure skating market. In Rochester , Minnesota , home of the PSA, it has already happened. There are currently 145 members of the Rochester Figure Skating Club which includes both boys and girls. The Rochester Youth Hockey Association has 226 registered girls on 14 teams; a difference of 36% in comparison to the RFSC. In the State of Hockey (MN), there are 126 high schools with at least one girl’s team. Massachusetts has 82 high school girls teams, Wisconsin 33, Michigan 30, and Illino...
Read more