Changes for Better or Worse?


Changes for Better or Worse?


Originally published Sep/Oct 2018 PS Magazine

 “We would not have change if there wasn’t any progress.” -Gale Tanger

ISU Communication No. 2168 was published on May 23, 2018 with little fanfare. The move to +5/-5 was expected. The Scale of Values were re-valued to capture the original intent and not place too much weight on a few selected quadruple jumps. Under-rotated jumps were addressed to now make the quarter mark under-rotated as opposed to achieving full value. Rulemaking today is more about correcting unintended consequences of previous rules. A back entry into a camel spin was considered a difficult entry until everyone did a back entry, and in most cases, better than a forward entry. Why do we keep making so many changes?
When Communication 2168 came out, I gave Gale Tanger a call to ask some questions to help me understand. “Jimmie,” she said, “we would not have change if there wasn’t any progress.” So true! Who would have thought just a few years ago that 6 or 7 quads in a program was possible? Maybe this is what bothers me. We have taken a giant leap forward in the execution of quads and now the ISU has appeared to put on the brakes, reducing the men’s program by 30 seconds and one jump pass. Additionally, the ISU is limiting the number of quads that can be repeated. The quads were also devalued in the Scale of Values. Instead of pushing the men to chase Nathan Chen, they are pulling him back to the pack. Why does it always seem that rules are written for the benefit of some and at the cost of others?
I’m sure those who author the rules would say they are protecting the integrity of the sport. Writing rules to promote better balanced programs. I’m not sure that’s the case, however. Is the ISU trying to make the sport better or just more appealing to TV? In the not too distant past, television demanded a more exciting visual sport- one that fit into the 21st century of X-games. The ISU made that happen. One former TV contract allowed the producers to approve or deny new ISU eligibility rules. Today’s rule makers are the same type who stripped the sport of figures and pattern dances to gain favor with television. The decision to make all senior level programs 4 minutes in length was also made for the benefit of TV. Writing the rules to create parody in the events will make for great rivalries and better TV. 
I actually understand the argument. It takes a considerable amount of money to run associations and competitions. Big money can only come from sponsorships and TV revenue. While we may complain loudly about the direction of skating, television coverage has been and will be the key to relevancy and survival. While we must make skating watchable, do the rules accomplish that? Time will tell.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Forgotten Art of Skating Etiquette

Image
PS Magazine, OCT/NOV 2010 This past September, I was in San Francisco for both the PSA Nationwide and ISI seminars. I was excited to be there as I was unveiling a new presentation/soapbox, "The Forgotten Art of Skating Etiquette." But before I was scheduled to deliver my new PowerPoint, I had an on-ice presentation to do. Standing in the middle of the rink finishing up my session, you can imagine my surprise as I was interrupted by this gentle voice from behind. "Excuse me Mr. Santee, I am sorry to interrupt…I’m warming up for my test and I need to use the middle of the ice…Is that OK?" I turned and just stared at him in stunned silence…Did he just call me Mr. Santee? Is he asking my permission to use ice he already had a right too? WOW was all I could think, and "Sure" was all I managed to say. Turning toward the coaches standing there, I said, "I’ll even get out of his way." I was so impressed with his demeanor that I thought to myself that if ...
Read more

Under Siege – Our Youth

It’s not figure skating. It’s not hockey. It’s not gymnastics or swimming, nor football or basketball…it is our children who are under siege. In 2010, a jury awarded a former scout $18.5 million dollars after the Boy Scouts of America was accused of covering up decades of child abuse. The Catholic Church has had to defend accusations from Canada, Ireland, United States, Britain, Mexico, Belgium, France, and Germany. Every year there is a plethora of accusations against school teachers….as recently as yesterday, a university professor was accused of watching child pornography on an airplane! As a father I used to worry about the influence of drinking and drugs to my children…as a culture, we turn to the church, the scouts, school activities, or sports to help keep our children off the streets and away from harm. But that seems not to be the case… and quite honestly, it is very difficult if not impossible to protect our children from the “landmines” that surround them. It’s not these act...
Read more

Girls - Hockey vs. Figure Skating

Jan/Feb 2013 PS Magazine In the November issue of USA Hockey magazine it was reported that in the past 10 years, participation in girl’s hockey has increased close to 40%; for the 2011-2012 season, 67,000 girls and women were playing hockey. If USA Hockey can maintain that pace, the number of girls playing hockey could exceed those who are figure skating within another 20 years. While rink owners and operators would love that, it should concern those who earn their livelihood in the figure skating market. In Rochester , Minnesota , home of the PSA, it has already happened. There are currently 145 members of the Rochester Figure Skating Club which includes both boys and girls. The Rochester Youth Hockey Association has 226 registered girls on 14 teams; a difference of 36% in comparison to the RFSC. In the State of Hockey (MN), there are 126 high schools with at least one girl’s team. Massachusetts has 82 high school girls teams, Wisconsin 33, Michigan 30, and Illino...
Read more